4711 Ice
4711

Menthol bomb. Remarkably soothing as an aftershave, but by the time that cooling burn dies off in 15 min, the smell is gone too.

I don't even think of this as a cologne. More as a freshener after working in the shop. I'll give it the point for being refreshing because it leaves me feeling clean enough to take a beautiful woman out to dinner, but not as a scent.

I've never been a fan of the original 4711, as it has always seemed a bit on the feminine side to me. However, 4711 Ice is a bit less feminine than the original, and lasts twice as long on me - which still isn't all that long. I'll give this one a thumbs up for smell alone, and won't count longevity in the assessment, since everyone knows 4711 has next to none.Renato