Notice: Undefined index: email in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 62

Notice: Undefined index: custom_title in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 63

Notice: Undefined index: timezone in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 67

Notice: Undefined index: visible in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 68

Notice: Undefined index: activity_visible in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 69

Notice: Undefined index: register_date in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 70

Notice: Undefined index: last_activity in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 71

Notice: Undefined index: trophy_points in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 73

Notice: Undefined index: gravatar in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 80

Notice: Undefined index: user_state in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 81

Notice: Undefined index: reaction_score in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 83

Notice: Undefined index: vote_score in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 84

Notice: Undefined index: user_group_id in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 90

Notice: Undefined index: secondary_group_ids in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 91

Notice: Undefined index: is_moderator in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 94

Notice: Undefined index: is_admin in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 95

Notice: Undefined index: is_admin in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 96

Notice: Undefined index: secondary_group_ids in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 100

Warning: in_array() expects parameter 2 to be array, null given in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 100

Notice: Undefined index: secondary_group_ids in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 105

Warning: in_array() expects parameter 2 to be array, null given in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 105

Notice: Undefined index: secondary_group_ids in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 110

Warning: in_array() expects parameter 2 to be array, null given in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 110

Notice: Undefined index: secondary_group_ids in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 115

Warning: in_array() expects parameter 2 to be array, null given in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 115

Notice: Undefined index: avatar_urls in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 126

Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in /home/storm/sites/basenotes-com/public/basenotes/functions/get_bnuser_session.php on line 126
EU to force change of formula for perfume classics • Basenotes

EU to force change of formula for perfume classics

Pin
Pin

Reuters is reporting that hundreds of classic fragrances, including Chanel No. 5, will have to be reformulated if EU proposals to restrict ingredients such as citral (from citrus fruits), coumarin (from tonka beans), eugenol (from rose oil) – to 0.01 percent of the finished product; and completely ban tree and oak moss.

Pin

The Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS), who are advising the EU, say that 1-3% of people “are allergic or potentially allergic to perfume”. The industry isn’t taking it lying down. Reuters say that “Trade associations including IFRA and Cosmetics Europe, whose members are perfume and cosmetics companies such as LVMH, are aiming to submit a joint industry proposal to the Commission by the end of 2012.”According to an article Perfume & Flavorist, IFRA suggested “using technologies such as smart labeling, telephone hotlines and websites to help consumers obtain detailed, accurate and beneficial information on fragrance materials, which would allow consumers to evaluate a product in relation to potential skin allergens and their own requirements”Which makes a lot more sense in our view.Further reading

About the Author

Related Topics

Comments

Showing 30 thoughts on EU to force change of formula for perfume classics

  1. I agree! Whatever happened to the concept of personal responsibility?

    Since it appears these perfume allergies are triggered by application, not by smelling it on someone else, surely it's enough to provide warnings on the product and let people make an informed choice whether to wear it or not. Mitts off my Mitsouko! :-)
  2. I'd like to see some hard figures on the effects of these allergens on people that come into contact with other people wearing perfumes. How many hospital visits? How many attacks? Deaths? Until there is scientific data behind this, it's just bureaucrats picking on another luxury industry so they can seem like saviors.
  3. So 1 to 3% of the population is enough to destroy fragrance, as we know it?

    I want to know what percentage of the population is addicted to alcohol? If it's over 3%, is the government going to outlaw the production of spirits?

    Gee, you can go down the list of things.....how about gasoline? Isn't it a carcinogen? So why not ban gasoline?

    The whole thing smacks of BIG BROTHER!!!
  4. Ummm you guys realise when they say "allergen" they are only referring to skin contact allergies. that is, an adverse reaction from spraying the perfume on yourself. this doesn't even have anything to do with making OTHER PEOPLE sneeze or what have you. when it effects someone else, it's considered an "irritant" not an allergen. so they are banning perfumes because 3% of the population cannot spray them on themselves... it's even WORSE than it reads.
  5. It's not big brother. It's corrupt, unaccountable capitalism. The political power is bought through money and the power comes with a license to print money.
    The people who make the decisions stand to profit from them and those who expose them are ridiculed.
    The regulatory bodies are funded by the big companies who manufacture the replacements for the banned substances.
    One day we will shove their captive molecules up their ars** while giving away free oakmoss!
  6. I think it is already too late to save the classics due to IFRA's regulations, but the EU proposed regulations spell the end of Perfumery as we know it. No more Chypres, no more Fougeres. Will we see skull and crossbones signs in our greengrocers? Lemons have Citral in their skin. Will we see the same in florists shops? For such a small minority (alleged) to cause such a destructive change to our history and heritage, is madness when it could be avoided.
  7. I am one of those 1-3% whose skin is irritated by certain fragrance ingredients. I use dye and fragrance free laundry and toiletries. That being said, I also own over 100 fragrances, only a very few of which have ever caused any problems. I know which ones they are and fortunately they are ones I really don't like to wear much anyway. I have always figured my body was just sorting out stuff I shouldn't wear. On a serious note, this is another reason I try to test fragrances before I buy. I have never once entertained the idea of ttrying to tell a fragrance house, let alone an entire industry they have to change their entire way of doing things. I can't think of anywhere else in a so called free market, that 3% of a population would dictate 100% of the market.
  8. Like Profumo Saggio, above, I suffer from irritant contact dermatitis from a few frags. Those that have caused problems, I just spray on fabrics, not my skin. Most frags are fine, though, and I can see no reason for this additional, useless legislation at all. After all, problems with nut allergies have been reported for years, but nobody's suggesting banning them, nor should they.
    And yes, I'm hoarding already. I can't imagine a world without N'Aimez Que Moi, Parfum Sacre, Ta'if, Paris, Samsara, etc., etc. Altered as so many already are, I don't see they how they could survive further doctoring, so I keep several backups for each now.
  9. This breaks my heart. I've dreamed of being able to one day affored Shalimar and no 19 and Hiris. By the time im old enough to affored them they probably wont exist. At least not as we know them ):
  10. Good grief! How is it that peanuts and shellfish are still available? There are people who have fatal allergies to those substances; yet they are harmless to most others, and somehow the human race still functions.

    I say we round up those busybodies who are advocating this outrage and dump them into a vat of pure oakmoss extract until they see reason!
  11. Sounds awful, but I think this is happening for business interests. There is no way it would be put into place if it take money out of the industry.

    Is there a good way to have sythetic coumarin, oakmoss and citral ? It seems like almost every fragrance I have has these indgredients. I just don't even see how it is possible. All the modern mainstream designers use coumarin.
  12. Oh, for Christ's sake! Somebody allergic to something. Let's start with air pollution and cigarette smoke; nobody's outlawing them. If folks are allergic to oak moss, tonka, etc., please turn away.
  13. It's not big brother. It's corrupt, unaccountable capitalism. The political power is bought through money and the power comes with a license to print money.
    The people who make the decisions stand to profit from them and those who expose them are ridiculed.
    The regulatory bodies are funded by the big companies who manufacture the replacements for the banned substances.
    One day we will shove their captive molecules up their ars** while giving away free oakmoss!

    You hit the nail right on the head!

    - - - Updated - - -

    So what happens when they find that an even greater percent of the population is allergic to the some replacement chemicals they're really trying to push? I'll bet you won't hear a peep out of the regulators, as they will work really hard to keep it from the public. How much more greedy and corrupt can they get?

    - - - Updated - - -

    I am one of those 1-3% whose skin is irritated by certain fragrance ingredients. I use dye and fragrance free laundry and toiletries. That being said, I also own over 100 fragrances, only a very few of which have ever caused any problems. I know which ones they are and fortunately they are ones I really don't like to wear much anyway. I have always figured my body was just sorting out stuff I shouldn't wear. On a serious note, this is another reason I try to test fragrances before I buy. I have never once entertained the idea of ttrying to tell a fragrance house, let alone an entire industry they have to change their entire way of doing things. I can't think of anywhere else in a so called free market, that 3% of a population would dictate 100% of the market.

    Thank you for sharing that and proving that these extreme restrictions are out of control.
Share this