Musk Cologne
Bortnikoff (2019)

The citrus opening is really noteworthy. It's quite natural smelling and for me is dominated by a delicious tangerine. Soon the florals join with magnolia, ylang ylang, tuberose and muget. The green tea also presents itself a bit later.
The musk is really rather mild, only slightly animalic but creates a warm depth that is pretty special. The base is sandalwood and guiac plus the musk and is well done. The blending overall is quite nice and ultimately this is a inoffensive, rather quiet after it settles and comforting fragrance. I don't love it but I appreciate it and do give it a thumbs up.

I'll start by saying that Musk Cologne is a well-made fragrance in its own right, but just not something I enjoy that much when there are many more affordable and more interesting fragrances in this genre. Musk Cologne seeks to re-create an 18th or 19th Century eau de cologne with a natural musk base. It does that, kind of.

The opening is a blasé melange of tangerine and other citruses that gives way, rather quickly, to a white floral heart, which in my opinion, makes the overall composition too sweet. This cloying sweetness persists throughout, and this is what ruins Musk Cologne for me.

The base has a touch of natural musk, which is observable at close range. The natural musk is a nice touch, but does not redeem from the cloying white florals and generic powder base that many Bortknikoff fragrances seem to suffer.

IMO better options are Guerlain Eau de Guerlain, Eau du Coq, Cologne de l'Empereur (containing natural civet), among others.

I've never been much for the cologne type scents. Fresh and light with citrus.

Then I smelled this. Talk about a beautiful scent!

The way this settles onto skin and gently radiates puts a lot of other scents to shame. It reeks of quality.

Not a lot of projection but you know you're wearing it and that's all that matters.

I could probably be happy if I wore this six days a week. Nothing should smell this good.

But a bit rich for my blood these days...

Bortnikoff Musk Cologne (2019) is a thing of beauty, but before I go into detail about it, I need to come clean about something. I'm not often enamored by the whole all-natural artisanal indie perfume subsection of the niche perfume world, and not because I like corporate-governed synthetic shill swill that smells like it was designed by marketing or machine learning either, I just hate the pomposity and hubris that always gets attached to what almost invariably ends up smelling like unwearable art experiments cooked up in a Greenwich Village apartment above a coffee shop with the tag line of "better ingredients equals better pizza". Well I'm sorry Papa John, but unless you pick up a thing or two about what smells compliment or contrast each other and at very least do a little of your own homework into chemistry (not saying you need a PhD in it or anything), I don't care how expensive your oud chips or rose oil is, because you're going to smash it together with sheer abandon and claim it superior to all commercial perfume on virtue of the fact alone that it's expensive and laborious to make. Granted, anyone making blanket statements needs to be self-aware enough to know that there will be exceptions that poke holes through such statements, and Bortnikoff has proven to be one such exception to the above statement. Need I say that there is actually a plot under the ingredients here, not just "it's real musk so it's automatically a master perfume", and that Bortnikoff doesn't try to pass off face powder spilled into spoiled coffee as high art? Yes, I'm still mad at Auphorie. No, I don't care if it's your favorite perfume house. I don't want to pay hundreds of dollars to smell like a garbage can, no matter how natural, rare or expensive the materials are.

Anyway, the premise behind Musk Cologne is to be a wearable potentially every day fragrance, an exercise in the classic French style of citrus, florals, and musks, made "the Bortnikoff way" with predominantly natural materials. The name "Musk Cologne" is a bit off too, as this is still an eau de parfum in concentration, but compared to some other things the house has released, might as well be a cologne. the initial envelope is a beautiful tangerine , orange, lemon, and bergamot oil mixture, all natural and devoid of any citral or boosted aldehydes to make it leap in your face. Instead, the citric sweetness and freshness gently wafts into your awareness before an indolic ylang-ylang note enters to add heft. The other white floral component here represent the few synthetic materials present because there is no viable natural source of muguet/lily of the valley, and honestly perfumers have been using stuff to simulate that since time immemorial anyway. The deer musk base is surprisingly subtle, but this is meant to be more about the combination of citrus and white flowers over musk anyway, and meant to be casually worn. The musk pairs with real Mysore sandalwood to create a classic creamy powderiness like you find in some turn-of-the-century fragrances such as D'Orsay Etiquette Bleue (1908), but rounded with the honeyed slightly-smoky edge of natural guaiac wood. All told, the only bit of disappointment if one really looks for some is that Musk Cologne tries to be so rigidly classic in design, but damn if it isn't a good take on what may be to some a "dated" style. Wear time is easily past 10 hours, although sillage is close to skin for most of it. Best use pretty much any time outside when you need something that projects.

Dmitry Bortnikov seems to have much interest in classic composition and innate talent as a self-taught indie perfumer, just as pretty much any other noteworthy player in the indie scene outside artisanal realms, like a Bruno Fazzolari or the late Vero Kern (RIP). It's therefore an unusual treat for me to get my nose on one of his creations, as like with most all-natural indies with a super-small batch release, his stuff is here today and sold out yesterday once superfans buy their backups on day one and scalpers snatch the rest for a good flip on eBay afterward. Luckily, Musk Cologne seems to be one that gets successive batches made of it, so maybe there isn't a specific irreplaceable vintage tincture of musk or sandalwood oil being used, and Dmitry is likely using the closest thing to a "communelle" of these ingredients as he can possibly make given their availability. It's all speculation at this point, but whatever the reason, it seems you can still pick it up reasonably in the short term future from authorized sellers unless that changes. After another rewarding experience with Bonheur (2018), one of his here-today-gone-forever fragrances, I'm convinced he's trying to frame himself as the closest modern equivalent to a pre-industrial 19th century perfumer as you can get, back when they were less chemist and more apothecary. Scarcity and price aside, Musk Cologne shows me that wearable and artistically satisfying experiences where blending is just as important as distillation of materials can exist in the world of artisanal perfumery, and that's exciting. Stylistic exploration may forever be trapped before a certain point in time, just because so many styles developed in the last 100 years are so heavily dependent on synthetics, but I don't think I'll ever tire of smelling a well-done citrus floral musk like this. Thumbs up.

Instant love for Musk Cologne by Bortnikoff! What a wonderful fresh dream of a fragrance with just a hint of real deer musk to give it some body and depth. This is orange/tangerine/lemon/bergamot in the opening but the deer musk is also present, playing softly in the background. The blending is divine with Musk Cologne and you could honestly wear this beautiful fragrance in virtually any situation. I pick up some soft ylang as well and the sandalwood and palosanto or "guiac" lend some foundation in the final phases. The one draw back might be the longevity and sillage as this becomes a skin scent faster than I'd like but honestly this is a must have cologne for me as it makes me happy as soon as I apply it. Two thumbs way up for Musk Cologne!!

Tropical flowers melding with citrus tangerine notes is soon joined by a rich musk and lovely sandalwood. These notes are constantly dancing around each other. There is also a hint of what smells like oud within this beautiful composition.

I get several hours in longevity with moderate projection, it does stay close to you.

All in all a lovely exotic smelling scent with quality natural ingredients.